Ethics is Not Always About Being “Right”

Often, it’s about learning what we care about most.

When I am chatting with a stranger on a plane or meeting someone for the first time, I know what is going to happen after they ask, “What do you do for a living?” I’ll answer, and then I’ll have some explaining to do.

I’m a healthcare ethicist. I spend my days improving care or clarifying difficult situations in an acute care hospital. But even there, I often find myself explaining what I do—mostly by clarifying what ethics is. Some people immediately understand, and others smile and nod politely as they change the subject.

People understand “ethics” to mean all kinds of things—a set of intuitions, a faith perspective, a gut feeling, morality. I can describe it in lots of ways, but one thing I almost never do is describe it as being about right and wrong.

Why not? Three reasons.

  • Talking in terms of right and wrong can create the impression that there is only one right answer or course of action. This is often not the case. Within the complexity of healthcare and health ethics, there might be multiple options for action in a given healthcare situation—some starkly different, others more nuanced. Often, more than one option could be ethically acceptable.
  • “Right and wrong” framing suggests that the same situation should always lead to the same ethical conclusion. Maybe we are trying to figure out whether to respect a patient’s choice to make a risky decision or to limit that choice to preserve their safety. We might be tempted to draw some broad conclusions, e.g. It is always right to promote choice.But ethical decision-making in healthcare is context-specific. The right course of action depends on the clinical facts of the case, as well as the values, beliefs, and wishes of the people involved. In cases with similar clinical facts, an ethics analysis can lead to a very different outcome, for instance, if the perspectives and beliefs of the people involved are different.
  • Talking in terms of right and wrong can also lead us to assume that if we find the “right” answer then it will feel right—clearer, lighter, better. Sometimes this happens, but not always. Truly ethically challenging situations often involve a conflict of values. We may have to acknowledge that there are multiple important things that we cannot live up to at the same time. When we have to prioritize one value over another, we can feel a sense of loss. We’ve had to give up something that matters to us.

In the most complex health ethics cases, sometimes none of the options feel good. Sometimes we end up with the least-worse option. The best we can do might still feel uncomfortable—or just plain bad.

Ethics is a conversation about decisions and actions that we can justify.  In ethics, we move from asking What is the right thing to do? to asking What are the best reasons we have for this course of action?  In other words, instead of asking, what is the absolute right option here, we should be asking, what is option we have the best reasons to follow through on?  What is most ethically justified?

The job of the ethicist is to make sure we are using a good process involving the necessary partners, perspective, and information to answer that question.